Ive gone through the novel and film multiples times and comprised this list of changes and similarities between. How does the ending of the shining differ from stephen kings novel related. Heres every difference between the shining book and. And we can see why its a book by stephen king, a film by stanley kubrick, and the. Mar 30, 2017 for the first time, the shining s producer and cowriter explain in detail why the horror tales ending changed from stephen kings novel and how it evolved again and again during the filming. Stephen kings book the shining and stanley kubricks corresponding adaptation are both staples of the horror genre, but theyre also very different beasts. In the film jack nicholsons character is called jack torrance but in the book hes called john daniel torrance. I remember a friend telling me somebody like jon voight should have played that role instead. He starts off with not much personality, which is kind of saved up for later in the story when the house gets in his head and he becomes a clown. The miniseries was a huge mistake except for the scene with the woman in the tub. The movies biggest changes from the book stanley kubrick took a lot of liberties with the story and characters from stephen kings the shining. Whats the difference comes at you this week with one of the most popular viewer suggestions.
Mar 25, 2012 well there was two shining movies the old version with jake nicholson. Jun 26, 2018 watchmojo ranks the top differences between the shining book and movie. The tension felt when jack jack nicholson chases danny danny lloyd through the hotel grounds is incredible. I prefer the movie because it gives us an unique take on the story perpetuated by stanley kubrick as one of the best films ever made. The film is an adaptation of stephen kings 20 novel, which is itself a sequel to his 1977 classic the shining. The shining book vs movie all the differences between the. Stanley kubricks film edition of the shining has long been one of my favorite horror movies. First things first, stuart ullman, the manager of the overlook, was way different in the movie than he was in the book. The intensity of the gothic novel came to life by the legendary stanley kubrick in 1980. Stanley kubricks classic 1980 adaptation of the same book.
For the first time, the shinings producer and cowriter explain in detail why the horror tales ending changed from stephen kings novel and how it evolved again and again during the filming. Top 10 differences between the shining book and movie. The book was admired by fans, but kubricks reimagining made it the iconic classic that it is today. But if youve read the book and watched the film, its. King felt that kubrick had twisted his story, ignoring the inherent evil of the hotel, and generally. We all know that the stanley kubrick version of stephen kings book the shining is great, but there was also made for tv movie by the same name that came out few years ago. The shining 1977 is stephen kings third novel, and according to wikipedia, the one that established him as a popular author. Watchmojo ranks the top differences between the shining book and movie. Jan 16, 2020 is stephen kings novel the shining scary, and if so how scary. Check out his first column below, exploring the shining. Then i love the book the shining it was one of my favorites by stephen king. Movie november 6, 2015 november 6, 2015 mkwierzal alright, i know halloween time is over and yummy turkey time has begun, but i only just finished reading a horror classic and rewatching its movie adaptation, and the differences between the two are so striking i. More famously, the supernatural room in the book is room 217, but the stanley hotel, where the film was shot, asked that they use a nonexistent. And as the movie has been watched and rewatched people have found an enormous number of.
List of differences between the book and film the shining wiki. Differences between the shining book vs movie page 1. Now flanagan has attempted to make a movie that serves as a sequel to both versions of the shining, mashing up plot points and scenes from all of the film s various, sometimes contradictory sources. Is stephen kings novel the shining scary, and if so how scary. Well there was two shining movies the old version with jake nicholson. Movie june 19, 2014 the shining, stephen kings third book was an instant bestseller and stanley kubricks movie based on the book went on to become a masterpiece in no time and is hailed as one of the scariest movies ever. What are the differences between the book and movie that. The film version made big changes to the character of jack overall, and subsequently, many elements of the story were completely modified to better represent the character the picture was working with. Stephen king wasnt a big fan of kubricks adaptation of his novel, the shining. In the movie the motivation of the ghosts is to possess jack torrance to get him to kill danny.
How does the ending of the shining differ from stephen. When stanley kubrick directed his film adaptation of the shining, author stephen king. The shining, the 1977 novel by stephen king, is widely considered one of the best horror novels ever written. Differences between the shining book vs movie page 3. Jun 26, 2012 the shining was the book which inspired me to write. The amount of changes is one of the reasons why king hated the film so much. Whats the difference between the shining the book and the shining the movie.
Nah,the christine book is much better than christine the movie and its not even close to being stephen kings best book but its still better than its movie adaptation. Nov 06, 2019 here are all the major differences between the book and film versions of the shining you need to know before seeing doctor sleep. Although some of kubricks take on the shining complements the book, king show more content. How doctor sleep is a very different movie to the shining. Stephen king s the shining is a classic piece of literature and stanley kubricks cinematic version shares the same cult status. I dont think a movie should ever be compared to the book it is based upon. Movie, hell be taking a critical look at movie adaptations of horror novels. The most striking comparison is the 1997 miniseries adaptation of the shining vs. The made for tv version of the movie is more true to the book, but i think the kubrick movie is slightly better. We enter the mind of stephen king and give you all the scary stuff the movie s missing. The book might give you an entirely different experience. The death of another character is changed radically in the film. A t book readings, stephen king sometimes tells a story about his only preproduction discussion for the 1980 film adaptation of the shining.
The eponymous shining plays a smaller role in the film than it does in the nov. Here are the major differences between the doctor sleep book and mike flanagans movie. In the book, he wasnt to pleased at the idea of hiring an alcoholic such as jack and in the movie he thought that hiring jack was a. Kubrick renowned director stanley kubrick was a master of his time, an auteur if you will, who drew his inspiration from various. May 20, 2015 whats the difference comes at you this week with one of the most popular viewer suggestions.
Heres every difference between the shining book and the film. Dick explains the shining in the kitchen and is not very kind to danny. The shinings 1980 hedge maze chase is one of the most iconic endings in horror history. But there was no sense of anything cohesive going on. The shining book vs movie essay 1092 words bartleby.
Top 10 horror movies that did something brand new s. In the movie, not only is there an overlook hotel, but meticulous recreations of the sets from kubricks shiningor best guesses at what theyd look like after 40 years of exposure to the. Whats different between the shining book and movie. Because of how much it deviates from the book and that jack was wrong for the role. Stephen kings the shining has maintained its cult status since its release in 1977. Stephen kings the shining is a classic piece of literature and stanley kubricks cinematic version shares the same cult status. Jun 07, 2015 whats different between the shining book and movie. It was also the first full novel i read coverto conver. Jun 05, 2015 stephen kings the shining is a classic piece of literature and stanley kubricks cinematic version shares the same cult status. Stanley kubrick made quite a few changes to the original stephen king storyline, keeping only the bare bones plot line of the book. Jack hopes the stay will be therapeutic and allow him to. Lets put the 1997 king miniseries up against the 1980 kubrick film and see what happens.
The reason why becomes obvious when you read the book, which still. The conversation when dick explains the shining takes place in his car, and he tests danny to see how strong his shine is. Stanley kubrick took a lot of liberties with the story and characters from stephen kings the shining. One man however, does not love the movie or the characterization, and that. The readers imagination and visualization skills play an immeasurably large role when consuming a book, whereas a movie is a screenwriters, directors, actors, art directors, set decorators, costume designers and cinematographers, and editors rendering of a story. We all know how intensely a book can be altered when revised from novel to film, but just what exactly gets lost in translation. A comprehensive list of all differences between the 1977 stephen king novel the shining and the stanley kubrick 1980 film adaptation. Apr 06, 20 a t book readings, stephen king sometimes tells a story about his only preproduction discussion for the 1980 film adaptation of the shining.
Doctor sleep, on the other hand, follows jacks son, danny torrance, years after the events in the shining. The main problem with kubricks adaptation, the story was holey. Dec 11, 2015 we all know how intensely a book can be altered when revised from novel to film, but just what exactly gets lost in translation. List of differences between the book and film the shining. So many people wonder how much of a difference there is between the film and novel of the shining by stephen king. King famously hated kubricks film, which was a lot more interested in ghosts than in alcoholism, so when he decided to write a sequel to the. The now adult danny uses his shining abilities at a hospice, where he provides comfort to dying patients, earning the nickname of doctor sleep. Then the new version who i cant remember what his name was but i know he played on the tv show wings. However, kubricks adaptation of the shining deviates from kings novel in a few significant ways, which puts the new movie in a weird position.
In the book in the movie the motivation of the ghosts is to possess jack torrance to get him to kill danny. What stanley kubrick got wrong about the shining stephen king has always disliked stanley kubricks film of the shining, and he has a point. The screenplay was written by stanley kubrick and diane johnson. Here are all the major differences between the book and film versions of the shining you need to know before seeing doctor sleep. When stanley kubrick directed his film adaptation of the shining, author stephen king hated it. For me, the books version of benjamin braddock is a goodlooking sociopath almost on the patrick bateman scale, compared to the films uneasy. Top 10 differences between the shining book and movie youtube.
So many people wonder how much of a difference there is between the film and novel of the shining by stephen. We have come to love and admire the shining as a movie, starring iconic images and jack nicholson as a caged madman. The movies biggest changes from the book doctor sleep, on the other hand, follows jacks son, danny torrance, years after the events in the shining. Whats the difference between the shining book and movie. Stephen kings sequel to the shining changed a lot on its way to the big screen. What stanley kubrick got wrong about the shining salon. The shining, the 1977 novel by stephen king, is widely considered one of. The movie, the shining, is a cinematic masterpiece directed by stanley kubrick. Stanley kubrick made quite a few changes to the original stephen king storyline, keeping only the bare. The death is also nothing like jacks fate in the novelization of the shining, written by stephen king. If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and dont vote in the other threads. Jun 05, 2019 the movie, the shining, is a cinematic masterpiece directed by stanley kubrick. The shining begins with jack torrance receiving a position as the winter caretaker for the overlook hotel, an isolated hotel in the colorado rockies. In the book, he wasnt to pleased at the idea of hiring an alcoholic such as jack and in the movie he thought that hiring jack was a splendid idea.
Book vs movie part 1 the book is hot, and the movie is cold. It is terrorizing audiences, but what was left out from the book. The movie is so different from the book its almost unfairuseless to compare both of them. Spoiler alert first things first, stuart ullman, the manager of the overlook, was way different in the movie than he was in the book. In the book, jack torrance went on a rampage with a croquet mallet, not an axe. Stanley kubricks the shining was released in 1980, and since has been hailed as one of the greatest horror movies ever made.
Doctor sleep movie vs book differences how mike flanagan. How does the ending of the shining differ from stephen king. List of differences between the book and film is just that. Kings book is a direct sequel to his 1977 novel the shining, and most definitely not a direct sequel to the 1980 film directed by stanley kubrick, which king notoriously hated. King publicly disparaged the movie so often that when he decided to do the 1997 miniseries and needed kubricks approval, since kubrick owned the rights, king had to sign a contract promising he would quit trashing the movie in.
Nah, the christine book is much better than christine the movie and its not even close to being stephen kings best book but its still. Top 10 differences between the shining book and movie subscribe. Why is the shining book better than the shining movie. The movie was better than the book, ergo, the movie is better than the tv special.
1691 1384 1170 1562 1090 299 847 543 1564 293 967 397 1501 1657 41 420 1060 1591 235 167 678 880 625 515 1164 756 664 1020 38 423 1354 393